Conversation
vaibhavbhalla2505
requested review from
Tyagi-Sunny,
akshatdubeysf,
rohit-sourcefuse and
yeshamavani
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
This PR introduces a set of Kiro “powers” for the ARC/SourceLoop ecosystem by adding per-service POWER.md documentation plus MCP server configuration, along with core steering docs for LoopBack 4 patterns and CLI usage.
Changes:
- Added a
powers/catalog README plus a coresourcelooppower containing steering docs (LB4 patterns + CLI usage) and MCP configuration. - Added per-microservice powers (each with
POWER.md+mcp.json) to document capabilities and enable Kiro/MCP-driven scaffolding. - Updated
.gitignoreto ignoreCLAUDE.md.
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 37 out of 38 changed files in this pull request and generated 25 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| powers/sourceloop/steering/loopback4-patterns.md | Adds ARC LoopBack 4 patterns/recipes and example snippets for common LB4 constructs. |
| powers/sourceloop/steering/cli-usage.md | Adds an ARC CLI command reference and MCP integration guidance. |
| powers/sourceloop/mcp.json | Defines MCP server configuration for the core sourceloop power. |
| powers/sourceloop/POWER.md | Introduces the core “ARC by SourceLoop” power metadata and overview documentation. |
| powers/sourceloop-video-conferencing-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the video conferencing service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-video-conferencing-service/POWER.md | Documents the video conferencing service power (features, workflows, env vars). |
| powers/sourceloop-user-tenant-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the user-tenant service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-user-tenant-service/POWER.md | Documents the user-tenant service power (features, workflows, dependencies). |
| powers/sourceloop-task-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the task service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-task-service/POWER.md | Documents the task service power (connectors, workflows, env vars). |
| powers/sourceloop-survey-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the survey service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-survey-service/POWER.md | Documents the survey service power (features, workflows, dependencies). |
| powers/sourceloop-search-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the search service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-search-service/POWER.md | Documents the search service power (features, workflows, best practices). |
| powers/sourceloop-scheduler-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the scheduler service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-scheduler-service/POWER.md | Documents the scheduler service power (features, workflows, dependencies). |
| powers/sourceloop-reporting-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the reporting service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-reporting-service/POWER.md | Documents the reporting service power (features, workflows, env vars). |
| powers/sourceloop-payment-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the payment service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-payment-service/POWER.md | Documents the payment service power (features, workflows, env vars). |
| powers/sourceloop-oidc-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the OIDC service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-oidc-service/POWER.md | Documents the OIDC service power (features, workflows, best practices). |
| powers/sourceloop-notification-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the notification service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-notification-service/POWER.md | Documents the notification service power (channels, workflows, env vars). |
| powers/sourceloop-in-mail-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the in-mail service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-in-mail-service/POWER.md | Documents the in-mail service power (features, workflows, dependencies). |
| powers/sourceloop-feature-toggle-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the feature-toggle service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-feature-toggle-service/POWER.md | Documents the feature-toggle service power (decorator usage, workflows). |
| powers/sourceloop-chat-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the chat service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-chat-service/POWER.md | Documents the chat service power (features, workflows, dependencies). |
| powers/sourceloop-bpmn-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the BPMN service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-bpmn-service/POWER.md | Documents the BPMN service power (Camunda integration, workflows). |
| powers/sourceloop-authentication-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the authentication service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-authentication-service/POWER.md | Documents the authentication service power (JWT/MFA/OAuth/SAML, workflows). |
| powers/sourceloop-audit-service/mcp.json | Adds MCP server config for the audit service power. |
| powers/sourceloop-audit-service/POWER.md | Documents the audit service power (archival/export, repository mixin usage). |
| powers/README.md | Adds a directory-level index of available powers and install instructions. |
| .gitignore | Ignores CLAUDE.md and normalizes the export-typedocs.js entry. |
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
Copilot reviewed 37 out of 38 changed files in this pull request and generated 3 comments.
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
rohit-sourcefuse
left a comment
rohit-sourcefuse
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Comprehensive PR Review
This PR introduces excellent documentation for Kiro Powers integration with 16+ SourceLoop services. The work is thorough and well-structured, but there are several important issues that should be addressed before merge.
Critical Issues
1. Missing Trailing Newline in .gitignore
The .gitignore file ends without a newline, which can cause git operation issues. Please add a newline after CLAUDE.md.
2. Trivy Security Scan Failure
The CI shows a HIGH severity vulnerability in minimatch (CVE-2026-26996). While this appears to be a pre-existing dependency issue not caused by this PR, it should be addressed by the security team.
Important Issues
3. Error Handling Missing in Code Examples
Critical services like authentication and payment lack error handling examples:
- Authentication OAuth configuration has no error handling for invalid credentials or network failures
- Payment service examples don't handle gateway failures or validation errors
- Audit logging lacks guidance for audit write failures
4. Testing Documentation Completely Missing
None of the POWER.md files include testing guidance, which is critical for service reliability:
- No testing framework recommendations
- No integration testing patterns
- No validation examples for configurations
- No guidance on testing security features
5. Excessive File Duplication
All 17 mcp.json files are identical, creating maintenance overhead. Consider consolidating or documenting why duplication is necessary.
6. Documentation Accuracy Issues
- sourceloop-search-service lists
loopback4-soft-deletedependency but doesn't mention soft delete capabilities - Multiple services claim "Requires PostgreSQL" but some support other databases
Missing Elements
Error Handling Examples Needed:
- OAuth authentication failures and network timeouts
- Payment gateway errors and transaction rollbacks
- MCP configuration validation and fallback mechanisms
- Environment variable validation at startup
Testing Guidance Needed:
- Unit testing patterns with @loopback/testlab
- Integration testing for multi-service scenarios
- Database testing with testcontainers
- API security testing examples
Troubleshooting Missing:
- MCP setup debugging steps
- Common installation failure scenarios
- Environment configuration validation
- Service health check examples
Positive Aspects
The documentation quality is excellent with:
✅ Consistent structure across all 17 services
✅ Comprehensive service descriptions and capabilities
✅ Clear installation instructions and workflows
✅ Professional technical writing throughout
✅ Good environment variable documentation
Recommendation
This is valuable documentation work that will significantly help developers integrate with SourceLoop services. However, the missing error handling and testing guidance create risks for production implementations.
Please address:
- Add trailing newline to .gitignore (critical)
- Include error handling examples for authentication, payment, and audit services
- Add basic testing guidance to each service documentation
- Include troubleshooting section in main README
The security scan failure should be addressed separately as it's a pre-existing dependency issue.
vaibhavbhalla2505
force-pushed
the
feature/kiro-power
branch
4 times, most recently
from
ec8f478 to
b7d1e0e
Compare
vaibhavbhalla2505
force-pushed
the
feature/kiro-power
branch
4 times, most recently
from
1b518af to
5683c85
Compare
vaibhavbhalla2505
force-pushed
the
feature/kiro-power
branch
from
5683c85 to
c2148c9
Compare
SonarQube reviewer guideSummary: Adds comprehensive Kiro Powers documentation and integration for ARC microservices, enabling AI-assisted development with the Kiro IDE. Review Focus: This PR introduces 17 new Kiro Powers covering all major ARC microservices. Key areas to verify:
Start review at:
|
Description
This pull request introduces and documents a set of "powers" for the ARC microservice catalog, providing specialized context and integration for Kiro agents with SourceLoop services. It adds comprehensive documentation and configuration for several microservices, including authentication, audit logging, BPMN workflow, chat, and feature toggle services. Each service now includes detailed instructions, best practices, and configuration for Kiro's MCP server integration.
Key changes by theme:
Documentation and Service Introduction
Added a new
README.mdin thepowersdirectory describing the ARC by SourceLoop powers, listing available services, and providing installation instructions and directory structure details.Introduced detailed
POWER.mddocumentation for the following services, each outlining features, usage, workflows, best practices, environment variables, and dependencies:sourceloop-authentication-servicesourceloop-audit-servicesourceloop-bpmn-servicesourceloop-chat-servicesourceloop-feature-toggle-serviceMCP Server Configuration
mcp.jsonfiles for each power (sourceloop-authentication-service,sourceloop-audit-service,sourceloop-bpmn-service,sourceloop-chat-service,sourceloop-feature-toggle-service), configuring thesourceloop-cliMCP server to enable standardized scaffolding and management via Kiro IDE or CLI.These changes collectively standardize the onboarding and integration process for SourceLoop microservices within the ARC ecosystem, making it easier for developers to discover, scaffold, and extend these services using Kiro Powers and the MCP server.
Fixes # (issue)
Type of change
Please delete options that are not relevant.
Checklist:
How to use this:
Open the project in the Kiro IDE and navigate to the Powers section. Firstly ensure that your MCP is configured correctly and is properly connected to the project environment.Add or enable the configured power (e.g., ) that was introduced in this change. Once the power is added, provide the required input parameters if applicable, and execute the power directly from the Kiro IDE. Verify that the power executes successfully without any errors and produces the expected output or performs the intended action. Successful execution confirms that the MCP configuration and Kiro Power integration are working correctly.